Ankle ligament problems – sprains and instability
The ankle joint is a hinge between the leg and the foot. The bones of the leg (tibia and fibula) form a sort of slot and the curved top bone of the foot (talus) fits between them. The talus is held to the tibia and fibula by strong bands of tissue called ligaments. Each ligament is made of many strands or fibres of a material called collagen, which is extremely strong.
The ligament on the inside of the ankle (medial or deltoid ligament) has two layers; the deepest one is most important. This ligament is mainly torn in association with severe fractures of the ankle bones.
The ligament on the outside of the ankle (lateral ligament) is made up of three separate bands: one at the front (anterior talo-fibular ligament), one in the middle (calcaneo-fibular ligament) and one at the back (posterior talo-fibular ligament). The front band is the usual ligament injured in sprains or tears of the ankle ligaments, and the middle band is sometimes affected.
The tibia and fibula have a small joint between themselves just above the ankle. This also has strong ligaments, one at the front and one at the back. (tibio-fibular ligaments). The ligament at the front is involved in 10-20% of ankle sprains; the ligament at the back, like the deltoid ligament, is mainly damaged in association with severe fractures of the ankle bones.
Most ankle ligament injuries are caused when the foot twists so that the sole is pointing inwards (inversion), usually when the foot is pointing downwards rather than flat on the ground. When this happens, the full force of the body’s movement is placed on the anterior talo-fibular ligament. This may stretch, with tearing of some of its fibres (sprain) or it may tear completely. If there is a major injury of the anterior talo-fibular ligament, the forces transfer to the calcaneo-fibular ligament and the tibio-fibular ligaments, which may also be sprained or torn. Occasionally small pieces of bone may be torn off with the ligaments.
In a few cases, a twisting force on the ankle may cause other damage. The bones around the ankle may be broken, a piece of the joint surface inside the ankle may be chipped off, ligaments connecting other bones in the foot may be sprained or torn, or the tendons around the ankle may be damaged.
Most ankle sprains are fairly minor injuries which will get better with simple self-care treatment. For a south Indian it is easy to remember the word RICE which forms the basic treatment of a sprained joint:
Although a couple of days rest is useful, it is best to start taking some weight on the injured ankle reasonably soon after injury, usually within 2-3 days. Also start to exercise and stretch the injured ankle as soon as possible after the injury.
Normally a sprained ankle will recover within 6-8 weeks, although it may tend to swell for a few weeks longer.
Basically, if you have a severe ankle injury it is best to get professional advice immediately. Things that suggest a severe injury include:
Most ankle injuries get better completely and cause no long-term problems. Sometimes, however, there is some permanent damage to the ankle. The ligaments may fail to heal properly and become weak, or there may be damage to the joint itself or some other structure nearby.
Most importantly, an ankle ligament injury also damages the small nerve endings in the joint and ligaments. These endings are very important, as they tell your brain where your ankle is and what position it is in (they are called “proprioceptive nerves”). Your brain relies on this information to control the muscles which move and protect your ankle. If these nerve endings are not working properly, your brain does not get reliable information and the muscles around your ankle may not work together properly. You would feel this as a tendency for your ankle to “give way”, often with minor stresses. This might make you prone to repeated ankle sprains. This is referred to as “ankle instability” and is more commonly due to damage to the proprioceptive nerves than actual weakness of the ligaments.
Foot and Ankle Surgeon should examine you and he/she will try to see if there is anything, which makes you more liable to ankle instability than average. They will look for any sign that you have some other problem around your ankle, such as damage to the joint surface. They will stretch your ankle in various directions to see if the ligaments are abnormally weak.
An Xray will usually be taken to see if there is any damage to the bones of your ankle. Ligaments do not show on Xrays. Ligament damage can be shown by taking Xrays with your ankle stretched in various directions (“stress views”), by injecting dye into your ankle or around a neighbouring tendon, or with a magnetic (MRI) scan. However, these special tests are usually not needed at first.
As most people with ankle instability have proprioceptive nerves which are not working properly, the first treatment is a physiotherapy programme to re-train these nerves how to respond to movements of the ankle, by doing various exercises and activities. If your ankle or Achilles tendon are stiff, you will also be shown exercises to stretch these, and the strength of the muscles around the ankle will be increased by exercises. If your foot shape makes you prone to extra stress on the ankle ligaments, a moulded insole may be advised for your shoe to reduce these stresses.
Many people will find their ankle much more stable and comfortable after physiotherapy. However, in some people problems continue. At this point the opinion of an orthopaedic foot and ankle surgeon would be helpful. If you have not already had the special tests mentioned above, these may be done now. The surgeon may also suggest an exploratory operation on your ankle (arthroscopy) to check on the state of the joint. If these tests suggest weakness of the ankle ligaments, an operation may be advised.
Most people with ankle instability will not need an operation. Even if your ankle still feels unstable after physiotherapy, you could try a brace rather than having an operation to tighten up or replace the ligaments.
However, if no other treatment makes your ankle comfortable and tests show that the ligaments are weak, an operation may help. There are two main types of operation:
the damaged ligaments are tightened up and re-attached to the bone – often known as the Brostrum procedure. This is suitable when the instability is not too severe. Its main advantage is that it causes less stiffness than the other type of repair, as it aims to achieve an anatomical repair of the ligaments.
another piece of tissue, usually part of one of the nearby tendons, is borrowed and stitched between the bones where the ligaments should be. This is suitable when the instability is severe or you may put severe stresses on the repair. It is very strong but often causes quite a lot of stiffness in the ankle afterwards.
You would usually be in a plaster or brace for several weeks after an operation and would need further physiotherapy to help regain normal function.
The other problems which may occur after a ligament reconstruction operation include: pain in the ankle, either because of damage at the time of the original injury or because the ankle is now tighter than before
numbness or tingling down the side of the foot due to stretching of one of the nerves either at the time of the original injury or the operation
persistent swelling of the ankle
Your ankle may be just taking longer than usual to recover. However, there may be some other damage to the ankle if it is still causing trouble three months after injury. It would be worth consulting your GP or physiotherapist.
You can’t absolutely prevent another injury, but there are things you can do to reduce the risk. Obviously, take care when walking to avoid catching your foot on uneven bits of pavement (especially when you are in a hurry or have had a few drinks). High-heeled shoes put extra stress on your ankle and should be avoided. If your ankle or Achilles tendon are stiff this puts extra stress on your ankle ligaments when you walk or run, and exercises would probably improve this.
If you play sport, you should take extra care to warm up and down properly, with plenty of stretches to your ankle and Achilles tendon. Strapping your ankle or wearing a sports ankle support may reduce the risk of another injury but this has not been conclusively proven. If your injury was a bad one, it would be worth asking a physiotherapist about a re-training programme for the proprioceptive nerves in your ankle. Your GP or sports club could arrange this.
Posted On 6 Jul 2017
How Are Slippers Failing You? The easiest pair of footwear, that does not require bending down to tie or strap…
Posted On 4 Feb 2017
BUYING SHOES Any injury to the foot can impact your ability to move. High heels and pointy-toed fashion shoes are…
Posted On 30 Jan 2017
A WOMAN'S ACHING FEET Many common foot ailments are related to choice of shoes, especially in women. In a survey…
Posted On 30 Jan 2017
The fibrous tissue that connects your heel to the muscles in your leg is called the Achilles tendon. Through overuse…
Posted On 30 Jan 2017
Foot and ankle injuries include the injuries in the leg below the knee and they are common while playing…
Posted On 30 Jan 2017
What are foot fractures? There are 26 bones in the foot, all of which can be fractured. There are different…
Posted On 30 Jan 2017
Forefoot reconstructive surgery is treatment for your toes to alleviate problems often caused by rheumatoid arthritis. Symptoms can be painful…
Posted On 27 Jan 2017
Lakeshore Hospital's Foot and Ankle Deformity Clinic brings surgical expertise in the correction of complex foot and ankle trauma and congenital…
Posted On 26 Jan 2017
Some questions answered What is the Achilles tendon? How does it get injured? How would I know if I had…
Posted On 25 Jan 2017
Some questions answered What causes pain in the heel? What is plantar fasciitis? I've been told my pain is caused…